Sections
  • Back


Home | Cinema | Input From The Man

Input From The Man

Frank Pierson, president of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, responds to my diatribe.

The review in question can be found HERE

 

MY LETTER TO THE ACADEMY:

 

March 26, 2002

 

Frank Pierson, President
The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences

 

Dear Frank:

 

Enclosed, please find copy of an article I wrote on the movie Hedwig And The Angry Inch As you may be aware, this wasn’t even nominated for Best Picture, let alone Best Actor or any of the other awards it deserved.  Such is Life.

 

Still, the Academy should give up its snobby attitude and get back to the basics.  Film is the most powerful form of Art in existence, one that combines all others and transforms Expression into Experience.  Considering you head this Academy, I’m sure you realize this, for there’s no way someone would take on your responsibility simply because of prestige.

 

By praising only those movies produced by the Mainstream, you’re implying that such is the best of the crop.  How many times have you heard “movies aren’t as good as they used to be” come from someone who remembers when the Great films were honored at your annual show?

 

You need to keep in mind that MOST people don’t look around for creative films, they just go by what they read in Rolling Stone or who gets an Oscar.

 

I honestly hope this finds you well, and ready to turn things around for the 75th Academy Awards.  I look forward to seeing new faces at the Ceremony, not just pretty ones.  I look forward to being introduced to something truly remarkable, some amazing movie that the Academy genuinely feels deserves recognition.

 

Sincerely Yours,

Jake McGee

 

MR. PIERSON'S RESPONSE:

 

April 2, 2002

 

Mr. Jake McGee

Kent, Ohio

 

Dear Mr. McGee:

 

I was pleased that you took the time to write us and set down your objections to our most recent show, although I have to confess that when I then read your review, and found out that you regarded me as both an ignorant swine and a complacent elitist, I was a shade less grateful for your efforts.

 

Before you bury me in a mass grave with all my fellow Academy members I would remind you that we have never thought of ourselves as perfect or the final judge of what is lasting art.  Look at the year of 1939 for a demonstration of how human we are.

 

I happened to like HEDWIG, but then my judgment is clouded by having been one of Mitchell’s mentors at the Sundance Institute where (as I hope you know) he went to work through how to translate his staged musical into a movie.  I personally would have liked to see John go up against Baz Luhrmann because I think John is better, deeper and funnier.  And both explored fresh ways to approach musical film.  Sadly, my fellow members didn’t see it that way.  But I won’t sit by to see them insulted.

 

If you can bring yourself to watch our “foul ceremony” again next year, when you may not have quite so intense a rooting interest in one of the contenders, maybe you’ll have a more enjoyable experience.

 

I sure hope so.

 

Your concerned correspondent,

Frank Pierson

President

SHARE: DIGG Add to Facebook Add To Any Service! Reddit this
All Comments require admin approval.

Subscribe to comments feed Comments (5 posted):

star (04.18.2002) on 24/04/2002 19:19
avatar
revolutionary...your letter was strong...well thought out...to the point...intellectual and communicative...it proves that the pen is mightier than the sword as we express our beliefs to bring positive change...your review would have been more effective without the swell of emotion...but...we are only human and it is our emotion that drives us stand up for what we believe in...keep it all alive jake...you are something else
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
0
Phil C on 03/06/2002 18:38
avatar
Jake, you really are a complete moron. Do you think that Pierson is the final choice in the matter? Stop trying to piss everyone off, the movie sucked anyway.
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
0
Jake McGee on 04/06/2002 10:03
avatar
Actually, Phil, you're right. Pierson is not the final Vote in these matters, he merely heads the group. Although I didn't intend for him to respond, his comments have made me realize that the Academy simply goes with what they're given.

There are so many dominoes in this Thing, it's hard to point blame at one. However, movies are not inexpensive, and maybe it's those who fund and distribute them that are at the beginning of this atrocity.

Then again, is it us, those who review, that are at fault? I think that's where any Revolution can begin- at the root. If we see a movie we love, we should tell as many people as possible. Then, production companies will be more likely to fund, since they merely try to make money, and do so by giving the Masses what they apparently like.

On the other hand, could you make a better movie than this? Could you deliver a message as dynamic as "Hedwig"? Could you put together a story as remarkable as this? If so, then you have the right to say the film sucked.
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
0
on 03/04/2003 13:15
avatar
Jake

Fantastic man! You and Bobby Freville are both the next Hunter Thompson's. You should write an essay that says what he has meant to you - and how you can't keep his style from overwhelming your work - and tell everyone how many of his quotes and phrases you have to finally force yourself to edit out of your final copy.
You overestimate your cleverness, and do a poor job of covering up your worship.
the "BLOG" generation is the only hope for hacks like you.
Shlomo should fire you; but wait, you're not a real columnist.
SELAH
WHAT A HACK!
-an angry rotarian
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
0
Bob Freville on 09/04/2003 20:20
avatar
This "Angry Rotarian" is obviously a bitter fan of the Good Doctor's who wishes he possessed enough talent to write his own "gonzo journalism". This isn't the first article he has written this on. Lest we forget the remark he left on "Cocolobo: The First Whore". What I find particularly funny is the complete absence of any Thompson nuances at play in Jake's clever (indeed!) letter. First of all, I would hardly consider myself part of "the blog generation" and I don't view Mr. McGee in that light either. Secondly, this guy is badmouthing us for our supposed Thompson obsession, prattling on and on about how his influence overwhelms our work, and, yet, he feels no shame in referring to himself as "an angry rotarian" or spouting words like "Selah". What next, my pathetic little fledgling? Hmm? Perhaps "Res Ipsa Loquitur"? Or maybe "greedheads", eh? Shit, let us hope that this is just Asterix or the Good Doctor himself having a bit of fun...otherwise some poor scumbag is living a very miserable life. Oh, well. I guess we can only hope.
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
0
total: 5 | displaying: 1 - 5

Post your comment comment

Please enter the code you see in the image:

Newsletter
Email:
  • email Email to a friend
  • print Print version